Showing posts with label Legislative Continuances. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Legislative Continuances. Show all posts

Monday, March 5, 2007

Dallas Morning News: When court cases get held up by Legislature

Nearly two years after Tab Dotson died in a pipeline explosion in Wise County, the negligence case his relatives filed against the energy company that owns the pipeline has yet to go to court. And they'll have to wait even longer because they're up against an attorney who happens to be a state representative. "If you're a sole practitioner and you do 'street law,' that's OK," Mr. McDonald said. "If you are a hired gun that a corporation or special interest comes in to stop a proceeding against them, that looks like it could be abuse." Read the article at the Dallas Morning News

When court cases get held up by Legislature

Session again to grapple with ethics of continuances

Monday, March 5, 2007
By KAREN BROOKS / The Dallas Morning News


AUSTIN – Nearly two years after Tab Dotson died in a pipeline explosion in Wise County, the negligence case his relatives filed against the energy company that owns the pipeline has yet to go to court. And they'll have to wait even longer because they're up against an attorney who happens to be a state representative.

A month before the March 20 trial date, Rep. Phil King, R-Weatherford – hired to defend EnCana from the lawsuit in February – used a much-debated legislative privilege to delay it until the summer.

Attorneys for the family say Mr. King is using his political office to keep his clients out of court. Mr. King counters that the delay was necessary for other reasons and that the plaintiffs are putting political pressure on him so he will persuade the Canadian energy company to settle.

The case crystallizes the debate over "legislative continuances" used by lawyer-legislators to delay cases while they're in session. For more than 75 years, Texas law has required judges to allow a legislator to delay proceedings in which the lawmaker represents one of the parties, if the Legislature is in session. Not all of them use the delay, but it's available to the estimated one-third of lawmakers who are also lawyers.

Critics say it leads to abuse by corporations who hire lawmakers simply for the built-in trial delays. In 2003, the state began requiring lawmakers to disclose these continuances to ethics officials.

Dripping Springs Democrat Patrick Rose, a House committee chairman and practicing lawyer, said he filed a bill to kill the practice after years of stories surfacing over its misuse.

Supporters, though, say the practice is necessary because legislators, who make just $7,200 a year, need to be able to make a living outside Austin.

Curtailing the continuances would restrict the client's ability to hire the attorney he or she wants, said Jay Harvey, president of the Texas Trial Lawyers Association.

And some lawmakers are looking to expand the privilege beyond lawyer-legislators. A bill by Rep. Ryan Guillen, D-Rio Grande City, would allow lawmakers to delay court appearances in lawsuits until after a session, even if the lawmaker isn't an attorney.

Advocacy groups say judges should be given authority to deny continuances based on how long the lawmaker's been on the case, whether he or she is the only attorney in the case, and whether the lawmaker has background on the issue.

Tighter rules may have stopped former Rep. Gabi Canales, a Democrat from Alice, from delaying lawsuits against the maker of a diet drug who hired her immediately after her election – but before her first legislative session – in spite of her lack of history in such cases, said Craig McDonald, executive director of Texans for Public Justice, a watchdog group that sued Ms. Canales over the continuances.

The story made national headlines, and she lost her bid for re-election after one term.

From September 2003 to May 2006 – the first 2 ½ years of disclosure of the practice – 32 lawmakers filed 431 continuances. The high number is partly because lawmakers spent so much time in Austin in special sessions and had to postpone their cases more frequently, advocates and lawmakers say.

As of last month, 16 lawmakers had filed a few dozen legislative continuances in connection with this session – and the ones with the highest number appear to be dealing with traffic tickets or divorce cases or representing plaintiffs in years-long class-action suits.

"If you're a sole practitioner and you do 'street law,' that's OK," Mr. McDonald said. "If you are a hired gun that a corporation or special interest comes in to stop a proceeding against them, that looks like it could be abuse."

Jason Stephens, the attorney representing the Dotson family, says that's exactly what the energy company is doing.

Mr. King, the lawmaker, joined the case in mid-February, shortly after the defendants brought in a Houston law firm in January. A few days later, he obtained the 90-day delay.

Mr. King was "never even mentioned" in connection with the case until the family's attorneys declined to settle the case or go along with the delay request, Mr. Stephens said.

The lawmaker said he filed the delay because the opposing attorneys had asked a judge to disqualify him and he couldn't attend the hearing on that motion.

The case probably would have gotten a delay without him, Mr. King said, because EnCana had changed law firms in January and would have been given more time to prepare for the trial. The Houston firm hired Mr. King because he had done work for them in the past and needed a local attorney, he said.

Monday, May 15, 2006

Continual Perks Slow Texas Courts

Thirty-two lawmakers invoked a special legislative perk to delay Texas court cases 431 times in the two years from September 2003 through September 2005, a new Texans For Public Justice study found. The study, “Continual Perks Slow Texas Courts,” analyzed the 431 “legislative continuances” that Texas lawmakers reported under a recent continuance-disclosure reform.

Read the media release and the full report.

32 Lawmakers Used Perk to Claim 431 Court Delays

Thirty-two lawmakers invoked a special legislative perk to delay Texas court cases 431 times in the two years from September 2003 through September 2005, a new Texans For Public Justice study found. The study, “Continual Perks Slow Texas Courts,” analyzed the 431 “legislative continuances” that Texas lawmakers reported under a recent continuance-disclosure reform.

Special Sessions Yield Continual Continuances:
32 Lawmakers Used Perk To Claim 431 Court Delays

Defendants Account for Most Delays, With One Case Stalled 5 Times
Rep. Alonzo Filed 241 Continuances in Two Years


For Immediate Release:
For More Information Contact:
May 15, 2006
Craig McDonald, Andrew Wheat
Download PDFPH: 512-472-9770
Link to full report

Austin--Thirty-two lawmakers invoked a special legislative perk to delay Texas court cases 431 times in the two years from September 2003 through September 2005, a new Texans For Public Justice study found. The study, “Continual Perks Slow Texas Courts,” analyzed the 431 “legislative continuances” that Texas lawmakers reported under a recent continuance-disclosure reform.

Texas lawmakers who are attorneys in cases in state courts can delay proceedings in these cases from a month before a legislative session begins until a month after it ends. The seven special legislative sessions that Governor Rick Perry has convened in the past three years greatly expanded the normal legislative-continuance season. These special sessions helped to create more than two years worth of court blackout days during the two-and-a-half-year period starting in January 2003 (the new report does not analyze continuances that invoke the latest special session convened on April 17, 2006).

“Endless special sessions have created an open-season for legislative court delays that would have been hard to foresee when lawmakers created this perk for themselves in 1929,” said TPJ researcher Omair Khan. “The new disclosure law reveals that a few legislators are invoking this perk far more than we ever imagined.”

Rep. Roberto Alonzo (D-Dallas) filed an extraordinary 241 legislative continuances in this two-year period, accounting for 56 percent of all continuances. Rep. Phil King (R-Weatherford) came next, filing 53 continuances (12 percent). In both criminal and civil cases, lawmakers filed the vast majority of their continuances on behalf of defendants—many of whom may have had an interest in postponing a civil or criminal judgment against them.

Some lawmakers filed one continuance after another in the same case. Rep. Alonzo claimed the record, filing five delays in a six-month period in the State of Texas v. Omar Hernandez. Rep. King filed 11 continuances in five related cases involving a group of pawn-shop executives fighting over stock options.

At least six lawmakers claimed continuances in cases that named themselves or apparent family members as defendants. Reps. Craig Eiland (D-Galveston) and Robert Puente (D-San Antonio) claimed continuances in lawsuits that named them personally. Reps. Alonzo, Harold Dutton (D-Houston), Trey Martinez Fischer (D-San Antonio), and Carlos Uresti (D-San Antonio) claimed continuances in cases naming apparent family members as defendants.

Friday, November 14, 2003

Texas Civil Justice League to Honor The Legislature's Top 'Court Clogger'

Texas lawmaker Joe Nixon, who is to be honored today by the Texas Civil Justice League (TCJL), used a perk of his office to delay more Texas court cases than any other legislator, new Texans for Public Justice research reveals. Texas law allows lawmakers who are attorneys for cases in state courts to obtain “legislative continuances” that automatically postpone those cases for the period starting 30 days before a legislative session and ending 30 days after the session ends. The No. 1 "court clogger" is Houston Rep. Joe Nixon who accounted for 27 percent of all reported special-session continuances. “Justice delayed is justice denied,” said Texans for Public Justice Director Craig McDonald. “If the Civil Justice League must give this court clogger a civil-justice award, how about a bronzed bottle of Drano?” Read More

Monday, April 28, 2003

NPR Features TPJ's Work to Disclose Legislative Continuances

Public interest groups in Texas say some state lawmakers are misusing their privileges for financial gain. Businesses involved in court cases can pay state legislators, who are also lawyers, to request continuances on their behalf. Lawyers can get up to $100,000 to apply "legislative continuances," and judges have no discretion in those cases. NPR's Wade Goodwyn reports from Austin. Listen Here

Friday, April 4, 2003

TPJ Lawsuit Seeks Disclosure of Rep. Canales' Court Delays

Texans for Public Justice (TPJ) filed a lawsuit today to require State Representative Gabi Canales (D-Alice) to comply with the Texas Public Information Act (TPIA) and fully disclose all of the so-called “legislative continuances” that she has sought to delay state court proceedings. Citing the TPIA in a February 11, 2003 letter, TPJ asked three state legislators to publicly disclose all the continuances that they have sought since November 2002. While two of the ulegislators, Reps. Aaron Pena (D-Edinburg) and Ruben Hope (R-Conroe), provided the requested information, Rep. Canales refused to do so, saying “there are no records in this office that meet your request.”

Lawsuit to require Canales
to comply with Texas Public Information Act

For Immediate Release:
For More Information Contact:
April 4, 2003
Craig McDonald, 512-472-9770


Austin, TX: Texans for Public Justice (TPJ) filed a lawsuit today to require State Representative Gabi Canales (D-Alice) to comply with the Texas Public Information Act (TPIA) and fully disclose all of the so-called “legislative continuances” that she has sought to delay state court proceedings. Under state law, legislators who are attorneys can request an automatic delay in any state court proceeding scheduled around the time of a legislative session.

Citing the TPIA in a February 11, 2003 letter, TPJ asked three state legislators to publicly disclose all the continuances that they have sought since November 2002. Media reports had indicated that the three legislators had sought a total of at least six continuances this session to delay lawsuits against companies that marketed dangerous drugs see TPJ's Lobby Watch. While two of the legislators, Reps. Aaron Pena (D-Edinburg) and Ruben Hope (R-Conroe), provided the requested information, Rep. Canales refused to do so, saying “there are no records in this office that meet your request.”

Media reports indicate that Rep. Canales, working for the drug giant Wyeth, has claimed continuances to delay at least three lawsuits filed by victims of the now withdrawn diet drug fen-phen. That drug exposed millions of consumers to elevated risks of heart and lung failure. While Rep. Canales is known to have sought delays in these three cases, TPJ used the TPIA to determine if she had delayed any additional lawsuits. TPJ filed suit after Rep. Canales rebuked its request. TPJ filed a similar lawsuit in February 2002 against then-Rep. Rick Green, who initially refused to publicly disclose his continuances. TPJ settled that lawsuit two months later, when Rep. Green agreed to make the requested disclosure.

“Rep. Canales’ use of the legislative continuance appears to be an abuse of her privilege,” said TPJ Director Craig McDonald. “The public has a right-to-know how often she’s used the privilege and how much she’s being paid to delay these cases. It is alarming that some lawmaker-attorneys refuse to disclose their continuances. It is one thing to give special powers to public officials. It is quite another to let them exercise those powers secretly.”

While the suit only names Rep. Canales, the Court’s ruling may apply to every legislator. TPJ’s lawsuit contends that—regardless of where they are kept—legislative continuance records are subject to the TPIA and must be disclosed by legislators by virtue of the fact that they are filed and granted solely on the basis of the requestor’s status as a public official.

Under the Texas Civil Practices and Remedies Code §30.003, legislators who represent clients in state court during a legislative session or during the 30 days before or after a session may file for an automatic delay in the proceedings. Several bills have been introduced in the current legislature to reform or end the practice of automatic continuances, including HB 1606 by Steve Wolens (D-Dallas).

TPJ has retained Philip Durst of Wiseman, Durst, Owen & Colvin as its legal counsel. Mr. Durst (512/479-5017) filed the lawsuit in state district court in Austin.

* View the original petition.
* View the letter sent to Canales.

Friday, March 21, 2003

Lobby Watch:
Lawmakers Hooked On Stimulants Make Fast Money Delaying Justice

In recent years, manufacturers of weight-loss stimulants linked to thousands of serious injuries and deaths have retained at least four Texas legislators. Lawmakers hired by vendors of dangerous ephedrine and fen-phen diet remedies appear to have abused their offices to delay both court cases and regulatory restrictions that target peddlers of these dangerous products.
Read the Lobby Watch

Tuesday, February 26, 2002

TPJ Lawsuit Seeks Public Disclosure Of Court Delays By Texas Lawmakers

Texans for Public Justice (TPJ) filed a lawsuit today to force Texas lawmakers to publicly disclose any so-called “legislative continuances” that they have requested to delay court proceedings. Under state law, legislators who are attorneys can request an automatic delay in any state court proceeding scheduled around the time of a legislative session. “Letting lawmakers get court delays on demand is a practice that is subject to abuse,” said TPJ Director Craig McDonald.

Lawsuit Defendant Is Rep. Rick Green of Dripping Springs

For Immediate Release:
For More Information Contact:
February 26, 2002
Craig McDonald, 512-472-9770


Austin, TX: Texans for Public Justice (TPJ) filed a lawsuit today to force Texas lawmakers to publicly disclose any so-called “legislative continuances” that they have requested to delay court proceedings. Under state law, legislators who are attorneys can request an automatic delay in any state court proceeding scheduled around the time of a legislative session.

Citing the Texas Public Information Act in July 2001, TPJ wrote 62 state legislators who are Texas Bar Association members (50 representatives and 12 senators) to request information on any continuances that they had requested during the 1999 and 2001 legislative sessions. Just 14 attorney-legislators (23 percent) provided some information responsive to this request. TPJ received no responsive information from 48 of the 62 attorney-legislators (77 percent). Many legislators argued that they are not required to provide the requested information because it is not physically housed in their legislative offices.

The sole defendant in TPJ’s lawsuit, Rep. Rick Green (R-Dripping Springs), was the only legislator who said that he based his negative response on advice received from the Texas Attorney General’s Office. TPJ sued Rep. Green because the AG’s office has not issued a formal opinion on this matter and because TPJ believes that legislative continuance records are subject to the Texas Public Information Act. While the suit only names Rep. Green, the final ruling in this case will apply to every legislator.

TPJ’s lawsuit contends that—regardless of where they are kept—legislative continuance motions are subject to the Texas Public Information Act and must be disclosed to the public by legislators. The lawsuit argues that legislative continuance motions are public information by virtue of the fact that they are filed and granted solely on the basis of the requestor’s status as a public official. TPJ is not opposed to the fair use of legislative continuances but it recognizes that this legislative perquisite could be abused.

“Letting lawmakers get court delays on demand is a practice that is subject to abuse,” said TPJ Director Craig McDonald. “It is alarming that most lawmaker-attorneys refuse to disclose their continuances. It is one thing to give special powers to public officials. It is quite another to let them exercise those powers secretly.”

Under the Texas Civil Practices and Remedies Code §30.003, legislators who represent clients in state court during a legislative session or during the 30 days before or after a session may file for an automatic delay in the proceedings.

While each state court maintains public records of the legislative continuances that they grant, Texas has 411 state district courts alone, stretching from El Paso to Port Arthur. Savoring the scale of such an undertaking, Rep. Green wrote in his response, “If these records are available as public information through the courts, please feel free to spend your staff time and resources pursuing this information.”

TPJ has retained Philip Durst of Wiseman, Durst, Owen & Colvin, as its legal counsel. Mr. Durst (512/479-5017) filed the lawsuit in state district court in Austin. Typically, a party has approximately 25 days to answer from the time they are formally served with the lawsuit, which was requested today. A court ruling in such a case could be expected in four to six months. TPJ hopes that the case can be resolved as efficiently and expeditiously as possible, preferably before December 2002, when its lawsuit could be subject to legislative-continuance delays.