Showing posts with label Tobacco. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Tobacco. Show all posts

Friday, May 31, 2013

Lobby Watch: 'Little Tobacco' Fights Health-Care Fees

Smaller cigarette companies failed to stub out a bill in the legislature to make them pay the same health-cost fees that Big Tobacco pays. The bill's fate lies with Governor Perry, whose former campaign manager is a top lobbyist for Big-Tobacco.
Read the details in Lobby Watch.

Wednesday, May 11, 2011

Lobby Watch: Chewing Over a Chaw Tax Cut

The Senate tackles Rep. Allan Ritter's proposal to slash taxes on chewing tobacco on Thursday. Ritter says his populist bill is good for "all of us that chew tobacco." Evidence shows that Ritter's tax cut will escalate sales of chaw, which causes pancreatic cancer, esophageal cancer and mouth cancer. Texans would bear the costs of those chewers who cannot pay their own cancer bills.

Chew over Ritter's chaw-tax cut in the new Lobby Watch.

Friday, May 12, 2006

DMN: It's a losing fight, but cigarette lobbyists won't quit

Cigarettes were supposed to be the easiest target of all, but when the high-powered Light 'Em Up Lobby hit the marble hallways of the Capitol, nobody saw what was coming. Legislators, once set on a simple $1-per-pack tax increase, began talking about a complicated bond program to phase in the hike. They brought up money-starved health programs and addicted veterans and faltering small businesses. Read the article at the Dallas Morning News

It's a losing fight, but cigarette lobbyists won't quit

Talented charmers make some legislators rethink $1 tax hike

May 12, 2006
By KAREN BROOKS / The Dallas Morning News

AUSTIN – Cigarettes were supposed to be the easiest target of all, but when the high-powered Light 'Em Up Lobby hit the marble hallways of the Capitol, nobody saw what was coming.

Legislators, once set on a simple $1-per-pack tax increase, began talking about a complicated bond program to phase in the hike. They brought up money-starved health programs and addicted veterans and faltering small businesses.

That gave the lobbyists an opening.

"I've noticed when they put on the big push," said David Marwitz, a lobbyist for the American Cancer Society. "They get in the backroom ... decide a strategy, put ads in [lawmakers'] districts, [activate] phone banks ... and they've got the big lobbyists."

The biggest, in fact. Big Tobacco's toughest fight in years is being waged by a band of highly paid, talented and experienced former legislators, political appointees and close friends of the most powerful people in Texas. They're fighting an uphill battle with such finesse that they're actually, occasionally, winning.

Their effort shows the creativity and resourcefulness that lobbyists of all stripes bring to the Capitol. Their success is driven by personal charm, pushing the right buttons to motivate different lawmakers, and sheer relentlessness.

Tobacco lobbyists show all these qualities, managing to notch small victories despite representing an industry widely seen as no less than evil.

They seem destined to lose – a $1-per-pack tax has passed both the House and Senate, but it is held up over the Senate's desire to spend some of the money on stop-smoking programs. And they've had some stumbles, crossing other powerful lobbyists and losing ground when their clients launched ill-conceived radio ads.

Still, even their opponents are impressed by their effort.

"They're pretty resourceful," said Rep. John Smithee, an Amarillo Republican who successfully batted away the phase-in plan a few weeks ago.

Among those working for tobacco giants Philip Morris and RJ Reynolds are the intense and driven Mike Toomey, a former state representative and former chief of staff for Gov. Rick Perry; the imposing and raucous Stan Schlueter, former chairman of the House Ways and Means Committee; Gwyn Shea, former secretary of state under Mr. Perry; former Republican Sen. David Sibley; and former Rep. Bill Messer, a friend and adviser to House Speaker Tom Craddick.

Tough sell

They are tasked with defending the indefensible against mom-friendly, pro-kid, anti-cancer advocates with an easy sound bite and overwhelming public sentiment on their side.

"They've got a bad product," said Rep. Ken Paxton, a McKinney Republican and member of the House Ways and Means Committee that approved a weakened version of the cigarette tax. "It harms people."

Some of the lobbyists have suffered cancer themselves or have loved ones battling it. Some are still struggling to quit smoking, while some gave it up years ago for health reasons.

But like a defense attorney trying to keep a confessed murderer off death row, a cigarette lobbyist finds an angle he or she can live with – firmly believing that it's pretty hard to sell something if you wouldn't buy it yourself.

"It's definitely an uphill battle, but everybody deserves to have their story told and represented," said one longtime tobacco lobbyist, speaking only on condition of anonymity to keep tobacco as a client. "Believe it or not, lobbyists will refuse clients if they don't agree with them or if they don't think it's a good thing to do.

"And it's not about whether you can smoke or not. A product is being singled out for a tax. You just stick to the tax."

Other lobbyists contacted for this story, either personally or through their firms, either did not return calls or declined to comment on the record, citing instructions from Philip Morris and RJ Reynolds.

Bill Phelps, spokesman for Philip Morris, said the company wants to talk about the overall message – that the tax hike is too much all at once – and let lobbyists talk to lawmakers.

That's where the arguments are carefully tailored for an audience of one.

Lobbyist Ed Lopez of San Antonio visited representatives from his city and urged them to think of the blue-collar workers that populate their districts.

"They're saying, 'Think of the working-class people who can't afford to get away, and taking a break and having a smoke is their version of a vacation,' " said Rep. Mike Villarreal, a San Antonio Democrat who is on the House Ways and Means committee.

Rep. Veronica Gonzales, D-McAllen, was approached by the friendly, popular and slightly shy lobbyist Mario Muñoz with a reminder about how convenience stores in her districts could suffer if people leave the state to find cheaper smokes.

He pushed for her support on a version of the bill that would hike the tax by $1.05 over three years.

"They're supporting the phase-in as a way to allegedly assist retailers, so they won't be hurt all at one time," she said. "I understand what Mario's saying, but I haven't heard from any retailers about it in my district."

Ice-cold retaliation

Trying to lessen the blow, tobacco lobbyists even suggested that the state phase in the tax but issue a bond to get immediate revenue. That approach won support in the House initially but then fell apart.

"They felt that ... knowing that some of us want to provide more funding for public schools, and everybody wants to provide some property tax relief, the tax on cigarettes seems to be an easy target," said Rep. Jose Menendez, D-San Antonio. "They're aware of that, and they felt they'd come up with a solution."

Sometimes, the lobbyists' aggressiveness gets them in trouble.

Last week, lobbyists for beer distributors got a rash of reports that a corporate-sponsored phone bank was instructing constituents to call their elected officials and demand to know why cigarettes were being taxed but not alcohol.

The beer guys struck back immediately. Lawmakers warned that the beer distributors were ready to pit their own talents and connections against Big Tobacco.

The tobacco companies backed off.

Ultimately, the tobacco companies might have been their own lobbyists' undoing.

Sen. Bob Deuell, a family physician and Republican from Greenville, was all set to block the tax by using a rule that requires two-thirds of the senators in the chamber to consent before a bill comes up for a vote. His main contact with the tobacco lobby had been Mr. Sibley, whom Dr. Deuell called "one of the most honorable people I've ever met in my life."

Then the senator heard a radio ad paid for by Philip Morris that he found "offensive," "demeaning," "sarcastic" and "condescending." The ad, which accuses legislators of "leaving their common sense behind" when they go to Austin, was so disrespectful, he said, that he changed his mind.

"I'm tired of the rhetoric and the nastiness," Dr. Deuell said. "In fact, some of their lobbyists told me they had advised them not to run those ads, and they did anyway. ... The only recourse I have is to send a message."

Thursday, May 11, 2006

Lobby Watch:
Mouth Cancer Trumps Lung Cancer In Lobby

The smokeless tobacco industry quietly but dramatically increased its lobby spending in first quarter 2006 as proposals to increase tobacco taxes smoldered in Austin. Updated data since last week’s Lobby Watch issue analyzing tobacco lobby data filed by New Year’s 2006 show that the tobacco industry as a whole increased its lobby spending 4 percent in the first quarter of this year.
Read the Lobby Watch

Wednesday, May 3, 2006

Lobby Watch:
Dollar-A-Pack Tax Ignites Tobacco Hacks

There’s nothing like the dollar-a-pack tax on tobacco products—now pending in the Texas Senate—to smoke out the shameless tobacco hacks who have enveloped the capitol in recent months. With sin-taxes dominating Austin’s agenda, tobacco interests spent $1.4 million to $2.9 million on 52 lobby contracts by the first of this year.
Read the Lobby Watch

Monday, May 1, 2006

San Antonio Express-News: Tobacco legislation watched closely

They don't give much to candidates, but they do spend big bucks on lobbying. And for more than a decade, tobacco interests in Texas have managed to block a higher tax on cigarettes. This year, that long-running effort by the powerful tobacco lobby may turn to ash. A proposed $1-a-pack increase in the state's cigarette tax could well muster the votes to clear the Senate. It passed easily last week in the House.Read the article at the San Antonio Express-News

Tobacco legislation watched closely

San Antonio Express-News
May 1, 2006

AUSTIN — They don't give much to candidates, but they do spend big bucks on lobbying. And for more than a decade, tobacco interests in Texas have managed to block a higher tax on cigarettes.

This year, that long-running effort by the powerful tobacco lobby may turn to ash.

A proposed $1-a-pack increase in the state's cigarette tax could well muster the votes to clear the Senate. It passed easily last week in the House.

If the proposal makes it through the Legislature and Gov. Rick Perry signs it, as he has indicated he would, Texas would become the 43rd state in the nation, in addition to the District of Columbia, to raise its cigarette tax since 2002.

"This is a national trend," said Daniel E. Smith, national vice president of the American Cancer Society, which supports the tax increase. "No one likes taxes but the one tax (lawmakers) say OK to is the cigarette tax."

If the plan is enacted, come September each cigarette pack sold in Texas would carry a whopping $1.41 state tax, with the increase adding an estimated $750 million in annual revenue for the state.

Texas' neighbors impose significantly lower taxes: Oklahoma's tax stands at $1.03; New Mexico's at 91 cents; Louisiana's at 36 cents.

Tobacco interests last year spent $1.4 million to and $2.9 million in Texas to pay 51 lobbyists, according to the watchdog group Texans for Public Justice.

A handful of tobacco lobbyists refused to comment for this story, leaving others to describe their efforts.

Rep. Mike Villarreal, D-San Antonio, said he heard from tobacco lobbyists "constantly, every day" as the proposal made its way through the House Ways and Means Committee, on which he sits.

"They'd call me on my cell, they'd drop by my office. They were out in full force," said Villarreal, who voted for the tax increase despite the pleadings.

Over the years, tobacco interests have succeeded in keeping the cigarette tax at 41 cents a pack by arguing, in part, that raising it would create enforcement problems for the state.

"Excessive taxes can create an incentive for tax evasion," said Bill Phelps, a spokesman for Philip Morris USA, adding that when taxes become too high, smokers simply make purchases over the Internet or travel to nearby lower-tax states.

He cited New York City, where municipal and state cigarette taxes combine for an eye-popping $3 a pack. One survey showed 70 percent of smokers there reported buying cigarettes from a low-tax seller at least once in 2004, he said.

Whether industry lobbyists will be able to sell arguments such as those to the Senate, which is set to debate the bill in committee today, remains to be seen.

For one thing, cigarette taxes appear politically popular in a country where smokers now make up no more than 23 percent of the adult population. (Contrast that to the early 1960s, when nearly half of all adults smoked.)

Smokers face a coalition of grass-roots activists with some considerable clout.

"We're outnumbered (in resources) but we've got armies of committed volunteers," said James Gray, a Texas lobbyist for the American Cancer Society. "We're outgunned but we've got good information."

Health advocates say that on average, for every 10 percent increase in cigarette taxes, there's a 4 percent decline in the number of adult smokers and a 7 percent drop in smokers under the age of 18, with underage smokers more sensitive to price increases because they have less money.

Tax-increase proponents acknowledge that its Senate passage is no sure bet and say some supporters are reading the fine print and having second thoughts.

Sen. Judith Zaffirini, D-Laredo, vice chairwoman of the Senate Finance Committee, and Sen. Juan Hinojosa, D-Mission, have long supported a cigarette tax increase, both opted against sponsoring the bill last week because the money wouldn't go for tobacco-cessation programs.

Instead, most of the money would be used to reduce property taxes.

"This plan would impact the poor without giving them the means to help them quit," Zaffirini said.

Express-News Database Editor Kelly Guckian contributed to this report.

Monday, September 8, 1997

Time for Pols to Say 'No' to Cash from Big Tobacco

Now that there is zero public tolerance for deadly tobacco marketing campaigns that target women, minorities and even children, it's time to halt tobacco's other dirty campaigns-those that elect public officials.

Time for Pols to Say 'No' to Cash from Big Tobacco

By Craig McDonald
Texans for Public Justice, Director

Now that there is zero public tolerance for deadly tobacco marketing campaigns that target women, minorities and even children, it's time to halt tobacco's other dirty campaigns-those that elect public officials.

After decades of deception, the smokescreen surrounding tobacco industry marketing practices is vanishing. Even tobacco executives-who created their own Tobacco Institute to foment lies-now admit that they knowingly marketed deadly carcinogens. If the industry had not invested heavily in politicians and lied outright about what it has done to hook an average of 3,000 young Americans a day, public officials would never have given the tobacco barons such a long leash to peddle cancer. With all that has come to light on this detestable industry, there simply is no longer any excuse for politicians who continue to dip tobacco money.

Even Governor George Bush, who peppers his speeches with messages of personal responsibility, choked in late August when he took more than $50,000 in contributions from three top tobacco lobbyists, lobbyists who helped organize Bush's recent fund-raiser in Austin. In another troubling link, Bush's top political consultant simultaneously served as a Philip Morris consultant, taking about $175,000 from the Marlboro Man from 1991 through late last year. The consultant, Karl Rove, recently testified that Bush's policy is not to accept contributions from trial lawyers or gambling interests, but he does not turn away tobacco money.

The tobacco smoke emanating from the Governor's Mansion fails the moral leadership test. It also raises questions about why the Governor has been virtually silent on the state's tobacco lawsuit, which could recover more than $8 billion dollars for taxpayers. Bush's silence is golden for the tobacco industry.

Governor Bush is not alone. For representatives of a state that doesn't produce much tobacco, Texas politicians harvest plenty of tobacco money. Texas' 1996 congressional delegation took more than $335,000 from tobacco PACs between 1987 and the 1996 election. Rep. Tom Delay led the way, collecting $58,950. Next in line behind Delay came Sen. Phil Gramm ($46,100), Sen. Kay Bailey Hutchison ($42,923) and Rep. Richard Armey ($21,400). In contrast, ten out of the 32 members of Texas' delegation managed to get sent to Washington without accepting a dime of cancer money.

Back home in Texas, the Texas Democratic Party now forswears tobacco money but the Texas Republican Party took $96,000 from Philip Morris and the Tobacco Institute under the three-year reign of recently departed chairman Tom Pauken. In addition, Philip Morris has doled out $160,000 to Texas legislative candidates of both parties since 1991. During the recent legislative session, tobacco companies paid lobbyists almost $1 million to work over the Lege. These hired guns defeated a proposed cigarette tax hike and worked to gut two health bills. One bill requires cigarette manufacturers to disclose the ingredients in their deadly products while the other protects kids from the industry's most egregious marketing practices.

Taking money from a special interest implies tolerance-if not outright support-for the political agenda that motivated the contribution. With all that has come out about the tobacco industry angling to hook our children and lying to the public and their elected representatives, it is time for Texas politicians to line up behind the people they represent and institute a zero-tolerance policy for tobacco money.

Governor Bush is uniquely positioned to take a leadership role on this issue. The Republican Party of Texas and Governor Bush personally have been too slow to sever their cozy ties to tobacco money and interests. As the chief executive of the next state scheduled to go to trial with the tobacco industry, the Governor wades into a thicket of conflicting interests every time he accepts money from tobacco lobbyists. The Governor needs to tell the public and the tobacco industry that he will no longer traffic in cancer money.

The tobacco industry is responsible for the preventable deaths of 26,427 Texans a year, according to the American Cancer Society. The industry could not have gotten away with killing so many people for so many years if politicians were not on big tobacco's dole. Whether or not Governor Bush exerts badly needed moral leadership on this issue, it's time for Texas politicians of all stripes to refuse to take another dime of cancer money. Enough is enough, already.

Craig McDonald is the director of Austin-based Texans for Public Justice, a non-partisan, non-profit, consumer policy and research organization that focuses on corporate responsibility.

Sunday, June 1, 1997

Smoke in the Mirror: How Texas House Members Voted On Tobacco-Control Legislation

At the end of the 75th Legislative session, a majority of the members of the Texas House of Representatives fended off the powerful tobacco lobby to approve two major pieces of legislation. The report analyzes how Texas House Members voted On these tobacco-control legislations.

Read the full report.