TPJ filed an amicus brief with the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals today urging them to reinstate Tom DeLay's convictions for criminal conspiracy and money laundering. The top court will review the Third Court of Appeals ruling that overturned DeLay's convictions. DeLay was sentenced to three years in prison and five years probation for the crimes. The high court hearing is scheduled for June 18.
Read the full TPJ press release.
Read the TPJ Amicus Brief.
Showing posts with label Appellate Courts. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Appellate Courts. Show all posts
Tuesday, June 3, 2014
Tuesday, October 9, 2012
Appellate Court Hears DeLay Appeal
Nearly two years after his conviction and ten years after his crime, Tom DeLay takes his appeal before a gerrymandered panel of GOP appellate judges.
Read more about the DeLay appeal.
Read more about the DeLay appeal.
Labels:
Appellate Courts,
Press Releases,
Tom Delay/TRMPAC
Monday, August 20, 2012
NY Times: Judicial Elections and the Bottom Line
Tuesday, February 15, 2011
TPJ Lauds New York’s Move to Get
Campaign Money Out of Its Courts
TPJ today commended New York State’s decision to bar that state’s elected judges from hearing cases involving significant campaign contributors (lawyers or parties who have given the judge at least $2,500 over the previous two-years). The new rule by New York’s Administrative Board of the Courts is thought to be the most restrictive measure of its kind. Recently Michigan, Washington and Oklahoma have adopted judicial-recusal standards.
TPJ Lauds New York's Move to Get Money Out of Courts
TPJ today commended New York State’s decision to bar that state’s elected judges from hearing cases involving significant campaign contributors (lawyers or parties who have given the judge at least $2,500 over the previous two-years). The new rule by New York’s Administrative Board of the Courts is thought to be the most restrictive measure of its kind. Recently Michigan, Washington and Oklahoma have adopted judicial-recusal standards.
“Texas needs to take the ‘for sale’ sign off its courtrooms and adopt its own recusal standard,” said Craig McDonald, director of the non-partisan, research and advocacy organization. “The public doesn’t believe that judges who take money from people in their courtroom are impartial.”
TPJ supports legislation filed by Rep. Richard Raymond (H.B. 156). It would require Supreme Court and Texas Court of Criminal Appeals justices to recuse themselves from cases involving significant campaign contributors (lawyers, law firms or parties who gave a judge at least $2,500 over the previous four years).
TPJ Lauds New York's Move to Get Money Out of Courts
TPJ today commended New York State’s decision to bar that state’s elected judges from hearing cases involving significant campaign contributors (lawyers or parties who have given the judge at least $2,500 over the previous two-years). The new rule by New York’s Administrative Board of the Courts is thought to be the most restrictive measure of its kind. Recently Michigan, Washington and Oklahoma have adopted judicial-recusal standards.
“Texas needs to take the ‘for sale’ sign off its courtrooms and adopt its own recusal standard,” said Craig McDonald, director of the non-partisan, research and advocacy organization. “The public doesn’t believe that judges who take money from people in their courtroom are impartial.”
TPJ supports legislation filed by Rep. Richard Raymond (H.B. 156). It would require Supreme Court and Texas Court of Criminal Appeals justices to recuse themselves from cases involving significant campaign contributors (lawyers, law firms or parties who gave a judge at least $2,500 over the previous four years).
Wednesday, September 29, 2010
TPJ Urges Melissa Goodwin to Return $20,274 in Illegal Contributions
3rd Court of Appeals Candidate Melissa Goodwin has yet to return $20,274 in illegal political funds that she used to narrowly prevail in the March Republican primary, according to her most recent campaign reports filed with the Texas Ethics Commission.
TPJ filed a still-pending complaint about Goodwin’s illegal campaign funds with the Ethics Commission on March 25. As of her latest campaign report filed on July 22, Goodwin still had not returned the illegal funds.
Read today's complete TPJ press statement.
Read the press release from TPJ's March 25 Ethics Complaint.
Read the March 25 TPJ Ethics complaint.
TPJ filed a still-pending complaint about Goodwin’s illegal campaign funds with the Ethics Commission on March 25. As of her latest campaign report filed on July 22, Goodwin still had not returned the illegal funds.
Read today's complete TPJ press statement.
Read the press release from TPJ's March 25 Ethics Complaint.
Read the March 25 TPJ Ethics complaint.
Labels:
Appellate Courts,
Campaign Finance,
Press Releases
Wednesday, May 5, 2010
Editorials: Keller Fine Appropriate
Several major daily newspapers have weighed-in with editorials supporting the $100,000 ethics fine assessed against Texas Court of Criminal Appeals presiding judge Sharon Keller.
DMN editorial: Stiff But Fair Fine.
FWST editorial: Keller ignores due diligence.
San Antonio Express News editorial: Ethics panel at last shows teeth.
DMN editorial: Stiff But Fair Fine.
FWST editorial: Keller ignores due diligence.
San Antonio Express News editorial: Ethics panel at last shows teeth.
Labels:
Appellate Courts,
Ethics Complaints,
News Clips,
Sharon Keller
Friday, April 30, 2010
Judge Keller Slapped with $100,000
Ethics Fine on TPJ Complaint
Texas regulators assessed a $100,000 civil penalty against Texas Criminal Court Presiding Judge Sharon Keller on April 28 for failing to disclose nearly $3 million in real estate, as well as $183,000 in income from 17 different sources. The fine against Texas’ top criminal judge was the largest ever levied by the Texas Ethics Commission. Judge’s Keller’s disclosure lapses occurred in legally required personal financial statements that she filed with the Ethics Commission in 2007 and 2008. State law requires public officials to make the disclosures as a disinfectant against potential conflicts of interest. Texans for Public Justice filed the Keller complaint with the Commission in March, 2009.
TPJ's March 2009 complaint can be found here.
TPJ's March 2009 complaint can be found here.
Wednesday, April 28, 2010
Top Criminal Court Upholds Indictments in DeLay Case
Texas’ highest criminal court today unanimously rejected arguments by co-indicted associates of Tom DeLay that the state money laundering statutes do not apply to checks. DeLay aides John Colyandro and Jim Ellis were seeking to dismiss felony money-laundering indictments. A ruling in their favor likely would have resulted in the dismissal of Tom DeLay's indictment as well. Instead, the trial court will now proceed with the case against all three defendants.
Read the news story at the Austin-American Statesman.
Download the Court of Criminal Appeals' ruling.
Read the news story at the Austin-American Statesman.
Download the Court of Criminal Appeals' ruling.
Thursday, March 25, 2010
Appeals Court Candidate Melissa Goodwin
Violated Campaign Limits, TPJ Alleges
TPJ has filed a complaint with the Texas Ethics Commission alleging that 3rd Court of Appeals candidate Melissa Goodwin may have violated state election laws by accepting political contributions that exceeded campaign limits.
Read the full media release.
Read the TPJ formal complaint.
Read the full media release.
Read the TPJ formal complaint.
Labels:
Appellate Courts,
Ethics Complaints,
Press Releases
Friday, July 31, 2009
TPJ Petitions U.S. Supremes to Uphold Ban on Corporate Campaiging
In a brief filed with the U.S. Supreme Court today Texans for Public Justice joined with 19 reform organizations to urge the Court to uphold the historic ban on corporate campaign contributions. The future of the 100-year old federal and Texas state prohibition on corporate political contributions may be in jeopardy as the Court hears arguments in Citizens United v Federal Election Commission in a special September 9 session.
"Tearing down the wall against corporate campaign spending will hasten the selling of our government to special interests," said TPJ director Craig McDonald.
TPJ's brief and background information are available at Justice at Stake.
"Tearing down the wall against corporate campaign spending will hasten the selling of our government to special interests," said TPJ director Craig McDonald.
TPJ's brief and background information are available at Justice at Stake.
Labels:
Appellate Courts,
Press Releases
Monday, June 29, 2009
Former Appeals Judge Kenneth Law Fined $4,100 for Campaign Violations
Former Third Court of Appeals Chief Justice W. Kenneth Law agreed to pay a $4,100 penalty imposed by the Texas Ethics Commission to settle charges brought by Texans for Public Justice that he violated numerous campaign finance regulations during his 2008 reelection bid. Judge Law was subsequently defeated in that November general election. 
Austin: Former Third Court of Appeals Chief Justice W. Kenneth Law agreed to pay a $4,100 penalty imposed by the Texas Ethics Commission to settle charges brought by Texans for Public Justice that he violated numerous campaign finance regulations during his 2008 reelection bid. Judge Law was subsequently defeated in that November general election.
In a sworn complaint to the Texas Ethics Commission on September 17, 2008, TPJ alleged that Judge Law violated at least six provisions of the campaign finance laws, including raising $66,850 before appointing a campaign treasurer as required by law and failing to disclose occupation and employer information for more than 50 of his contributors. At the time of the complaint, TPJ noted that the violations represented either incompetence or indifference to the campaign finance laws.
Earlier this month, the Texas Ethics Commission determined that there was credible evidence that Judge Law violated six sections of the Election Code and two sections of Ethics Commission Rules.
Law was first elected to the 3rd Court of Appeals in 2002. In August of 2008 he joined a controversial ruling in the criminal case against Tom DeLay’s Texans for a Republican Majority (TRMPAC). The ruling used technical distinctions between “funds” and “checks” to suggest that TRMPAC did not illegally launder corporate political funds. Litigation over the money laundering charges is ongoing.
Details and copies of TPJ’s original complaint against Judge Law can be found here.

Kenneth Law Fined $4,100 for Campaign Violations
Penalty Follows Ethics Complaint Filed by Texans for Public JusticeAustin: Former Third Court of Appeals Chief Justice W. Kenneth Law agreed to pay a $4,100 penalty imposed by the Texas Ethics Commission to settle charges brought by Texans for Public Justice that he violated numerous campaign finance regulations during his 2008 reelection bid. Judge Law was subsequently defeated in that November general election.
In a sworn complaint to the Texas Ethics Commission on September 17, 2008, TPJ alleged that Judge Law violated at least six provisions of the campaign finance laws, including raising $66,850 before appointing a campaign treasurer as required by law and failing to disclose occupation and employer information for more than 50 of his contributors. At the time of the complaint, TPJ noted that the violations represented either incompetence or indifference to the campaign finance laws.
Earlier this month, the Texas Ethics Commission determined that there was credible evidence that Judge Law violated six sections of the Election Code and two sections of Ethics Commission Rules.
Law was first elected to the 3rd Court of Appeals in 2002. In August of 2008 he joined a controversial ruling in the criminal case against Tom DeLay’s Texans for a Republican Majority (TRMPAC). The ruling used technical distinctions between “funds” and “checks” to suggest that TRMPAC did not illegally launder corporate political funds. Litigation over the money laundering charges is ongoing.
Details and copies of TPJ’s original complaint against Judge Law can be found here.
Labels:
Appellate Courts,
Ethics Complaints,
Press Releases
Wednesday, April 1, 2009
Fort Worth Star-Telegram: Who pays the legal fees for judges charged with ethical violations?
Texas Court of Criminal Appeals Presiding Judge Sharon Keller has asked the state to pay her legal fees for defending against ethics charges because, she claims, the fight could be "financially ruinous." Well, that argument might be more persuasive if she didn’t appear to have plenty of assets — and then some. Read the article at the Dallas Morning News
Fort Worth Star-Telegram
April 1, 2009.
Texas Court of Criminal Appeals Presiding Judge Sharon Keller has asked the state to pay her legal fees for defending against ethics charges because, she claims, the fight could be "financially ruinous."
Well, that argument might be more persuasive if she didn’t appear to have plenty of assets — and then some.
Keller has reported to the Texas Ethics Commission income of more than $275,000 (including her $152,500 salary), plus a home in Austin and Dallas business property that together are worth $1 million.
But the Dallas Morning News this week revealed Keller’s interest in seven other properties in Dallas and Tarrant counties that are valued at about $1.9 million. Those apparently weren’t included on the financial disclosure form she’s required to file.
Some of those she owns herself, including two homes worth more than $1 million and a couple of commercial sites valued at $823,000. The News also found that Keller didn’t list properties owned by her law-student son or her family’s businesses.
Keller attorney Chip Babcock said in a telephone interview that she was working with an accountant and another lawyer to correct the financial disclosure forms.
Nevertheless, it’s clear Keller isn’t indigent, and it’s hard to justify giving taxpayers the bill to defend her on charges that she brought dishonor on the office she’s held since 2000.
Still, Babcock raises a legitimate question: If the State Commission on Judicial Conduct can hire its lawyer for $1 to bring Keller before a public hearing, should she then have to pay the hundreds of thousands of dollars that a defense is estimated to cost? Should a judge with means be treated the same as one without?
Keller was charged for declining to let the clerk’s office stay open past 5 p.m. on Sept. 25, 2007, so that lawyers for Death Row inmate Michael Richard could file a last-minute appeal based on a new issue the U.S. Supreme Court had agreed that morning to consider in a Kentucky case.
Keller’s answer to the commission’s complaint argues that she didn’t know the lawyers were delayed by computer problems but that, even so, they could have taken a hand-written motion directly to the duty judge after hours.
Babcock said he’s willing to steeply discount his usual fee or work pro bono on the case. But he can’t do that. The last time he tried, after defending Texas Supreme Court Justice Nathan Hecht in an ethics case, the Texas Ethics Commission interpreted the discount as a campaign contribution. Though Hecht’s sanction from the judicial conduct commission was overturned, the ethics commission fined him $29,000 for taking a donation in excess of legal limits and for not properly reporting it. (He’s still fighting that.)
It could be time for the Legislature to set specific parameters about legal fees for judges charged with ethics violations.
But we’ve got to hope that Texas judges will conduct themselves in ways that prevent more of these high-profile ethics fights.
Editorial: Who pays the legal fees for judges charged with ethical violations?
Fort Worth Star-Telegram
April 1, 2009.
Texas Court of Criminal Appeals Presiding Judge Sharon Keller has asked the state to pay her legal fees for defending against ethics charges because, she claims, the fight could be "financially ruinous."
Well, that argument might be more persuasive if she didn’t appear to have plenty of assets — and then some.
Keller has reported to the Texas Ethics Commission income of more than $275,000 (including her $152,500 salary), plus a home in Austin and Dallas business property that together are worth $1 million.
But the Dallas Morning News this week revealed Keller’s interest in seven other properties in Dallas and Tarrant counties that are valued at about $1.9 million. Those apparently weren’t included on the financial disclosure form she’s required to file.
Some of those she owns herself, including two homes worth more than $1 million and a couple of commercial sites valued at $823,000. The News also found that Keller didn’t list properties owned by her law-student son or her family’s businesses.
Keller attorney Chip Babcock said in a telephone interview that she was working with an accountant and another lawyer to correct the financial disclosure forms.
Nevertheless, it’s clear Keller isn’t indigent, and it’s hard to justify giving taxpayers the bill to defend her on charges that she brought dishonor on the office she’s held since 2000.
Still, Babcock raises a legitimate question: If the State Commission on Judicial Conduct can hire its lawyer for $1 to bring Keller before a public hearing, should she then have to pay the hundreds of thousands of dollars that a defense is estimated to cost? Should a judge with means be treated the same as one without?
Keller was charged for declining to let the clerk’s office stay open past 5 p.m. on Sept. 25, 2007, so that lawyers for Death Row inmate Michael Richard could file a last-minute appeal based on a new issue the U.S. Supreme Court had agreed that morning to consider in a Kentucky case.
Keller’s answer to the commission’s complaint argues that she didn’t know the lawyers were delayed by computer problems but that, even so, they could have taken a hand-written motion directly to the duty judge after hours.
Babcock said he’s willing to steeply discount his usual fee or work pro bono on the case. But he can’t do that. The last time he tried, after defending Texas Supreme Court Justice Nathan Hecht in an ethics case, the Texas Ethics Commission interpreted the discount as a campaign contribution. Though Hecht’s sanction from the judicial conduct commission was overturned, the ethics commission fined him $29,000 for taking a donation in excess of legal limits and for not properly reporting it. (He’s still fighting that.)
It could be time for the Legislature to set specific parameters about legal fees for judges charged with ethics violations.
But we’ve got to hope that Texas judges will conduct themselves in ways that prevent more of these high-profile ethics fights.
Labels:
Appellate Courts,
News Clips
Dallas Morning News: Keller's attorney says her omissions in disclosure form were unintentional
The failure of the state's highest criminal court judge to disclose all of her real estate holdings was unintentional and not an attempt to hide assets, her attorney said Tuesday. Read the article at the Dallas Morning News
Wednesday, April 1, 2009
By STEVE McGONIGLE / The Dallas Morning News
smcgonigle@dallasnews.com
The failure of the state's highest criminal court judge to disclose all of her real estate holdings was unintentional and not an attempt to hide assets, her attorney said Tuesday.
Sharon Keller's repeated omissions from sworn financial statements she was required by law to file appear to be the result of a "clerical error" and the judge not knowing that her father had put properties under her name, attorney Ed Shack said.
Keller, presiding judge of the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals, began reviewing her holdings after The Dallas Morning News reported Monday that she had not disclosed at least seven properties valued at $1.9 million. When the review is complete, she will file an amended financial report, Shack said.
"It's absolutely an inadvertent error," Shack said. "Unfortunately, she made it, and she's going to try to correct it."
Keller already faces ethics charges by the state Commission on Judicial Conduct stemming from allegations that at 5 p.m. she closed the court to a last-minute death penalty appeal. The condemned inmate was executed a few hours after being shut out.
The judge has asked the state to pay her attorney's fees, claiming that the costs of her defense could be financially devastating.
Accusations
On Tuesday, a liberal watchdog group, Texans for Public Justice, filed new civil and criminal complaints accusing Keller of violating ethics laws by failing to disclose her assets in a series of sworn statements filed with the Texas Ethics Commission.
The group contended that Keller did not list 11 properties in which she may have had an interest, nor did she list herself as an officer or director of three family corporations.
"It seems like she doesn't take public service as seriously as Texas' highest judge should," said Craig McDonald, executive director of the Austin-based organization.
The complaints were filed with the ethics commission and the Travis County attorney's office. If upheld, they could subject Keller to fines of up to $10,000 per violation or a possible jail term of up to six months.
Omissions
The News found Keller had not disclosed seven residential and commercial properties in which she was listed as owner in tax and deed records. Among the properties were two homes in the Keller family compound on Garland Road worth about $1 million.
Other omissions included a vacant commercial lot in Euless and an occupied commercial property adjacent to Keller's Drive-In, a well-known hamburger restaurant on East Northwest Highway operated by her father, Jack Keller. Together, the two commercial properties are valued at $823,000, records show.
Shack said the judge told him that she had listed the Garland Road homes on her annual financial statement through 2002. After that time, he said, the two properties "dropped off somehow, and she doesn't know why."
Some of the other omitted properties may have been listed in records under her name by her father without her knowledge, Shack said. She, her father and his attorney are trying to determine which of those properties should be disclosed, Shack said.
Jack Keller, whose nickname is Cactus Jack, made a fortune through his restaurant business along with property investments and oil speculation. Records show he, his wife and four children have extensive property holdings worth tens of millions of dollars
The News also reported that Keller did not disclose she was an officer, director or beneficiary of two family corporations and a family trust. Those entities are listed as owners of property worth more than $3 million, records show.
State law does not require an officeholder to disclose assets held by corporations in which they have less than a 50 percent interest. Keller did not list the corporations on her annual statements and did not disclose their property holdings.
Shack said he did not know about those omissions and couldn't comment.
Keller, a former Dallas County prosecutor, has been on the appeals court since 1995, and has been presiding judge since 2001.
Impeachment bill
Keller also faces possible impeachment in the Texas House related to her role in allegedly denying court access to death row inmate Michael Richard in 2007. State Rep. Lon Burnam, D-Fort Worth, said he believed the latest disclosure about Keller's financial statements increases the chances that his impeachment proposal will receive a hearing.
Keller has denied any wrongdoing. In a response to the ethics charges filed with the judicial conduct commission, her attorney in that case claimed the charges were unconstitutional because the commission had refused to pay for his legal services.
Lawyer Chip Babcock said Keller's defense costs could be "financially ruinous." He said he based his assessment on Keller's $152,500 salary and some rental income. He was not aware of the full extent of her holdings, he said, until told by The News.
On Tuesday, Babcock said his legal position on Keller's costs had not changed. But he referred calls about the latest ethics complaints to Shack.
Shack is a former attorney with the Texas secretary of state whose clients have included state Supreme Court Justice Nathan Hecht and Lt. Gov. David Dewhurst.
Justice Hecht is appealing a ruling by the state ethics commission that he received an improper gift of reduced legal services from Babcock's law firm.
Texans for Public Justice has accused Dewhurst, one of the state's wealthiest officeholders, of failing to make full disclosure of assets in a blind trust. The complaint against the lieutenant governor is pending.
Keller's attorney says her omissions in disclosure form were unintentional
Wednesday, April 1, 2009
By STEVE McGONIGLE / The Dallas Morning News
smcgonigle@dallasnews.com
The failure of the state's highest criminal court judge to disclose all of her real estate holdings was unintentional and not an attempt to hide assets, her attorney said Tuesday.
Sharon Keller's repeated omissions from sworn financial statements she was required by law to file appear to be the result of a "clerical error" and the judge not knowing that her father had put properties under her name, attorney Ed Shack said.
Keller, presiding judge of the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals, began reviewing her holdings after The Dallas Morning News reported Monday that she had not disclosed at least seven properties valued at $1.9 million. When the review is complete, she will file an amended financial report, Shack said.
"It's absolutely an inadvertent error," Shack said. "Unfortunately, she made it, and she's going to try to correct it."
Keller already faces ethics charges by the state Commission on Judicial Conduct stemming from allegations that at 5 p.m. she closed the court to a last-minute death penalty appeal. The condemned inmate was executed a few hours after being shut out.
The judge has asked the state to pay her attorney's fees, claiming that the costs of her defense could be financially devastating.
Accusations
On Tuesday, a liberal watchdog group, Texans for Public Justice, filed new civil and criminal complaints accusing Keller of violating ethics laws by failing to disclose her assets in a series of sworn statements filed with the Texas Ethics Commission.
The group contended that Keller did not list 11 properties in which she may have had an interest, nor did she list herself as an officer or director of three family corporations.
"It seems like she doesn't take public service as seriously as Texas' highest judge should," said Craig McDonald, executive director of the Austin-based organization.
The complaints were filed with the ethics commission and the Travis County attorney's office. If upheld, they could subject Keller to fines of up to $10,000 per violation or a possible jail term of up to six months.
Omissions
The News found Keller had not disclosed seven residential and commercial properties in which she was listed as owner in tax and deed records. Among the properties were two homes in the Keller family compound on Garland Road worth about $1 million.
Other omissions included a vacant commercial lot in Euless and an occupied commercial property adjacent to Keller's Drive-In, a well-known hamburger restaurant on East Northwest Highway operated by her father, Jack Keller. Together, the two commercial properties are valued at $823,000, records show.
Shack said the judge told him that she had listed the Garland Road homes on her annual financial statement through 2002. After that time, he said, the two properties "dropped off somehow, and she doesn't know why."
Some of the other omitted properties may have been listed in records under her name by her father without her knowledge, Shack said. She, her father and his attorney are trying to determine which of those properties should be disclosed, Shack said.
Jack Keller, whose nickname is Cactus Jack, made a fortune through his restaurant business along with property investments and oil speculation. Records show he, his wife and four children have extensive property holdings worth tens of millions of dollars
The News also reported that Keller did not disclose she was an officer, director or beneficiary of two family corporations and a family trust. Those entities are listed as owners of property worth more than $3 million, records show.
State law does not require an officeholder to disclose assets held by corporations in which they have less than a 50 percent interest. Keller did not list the corporations on her annual statements and did not disclose their property holdings.
Shack said he did not know about those omissions and couldn't comment.
Keller, a former Dallas County prosecutor, has been on the appeals court since 1995, and has been presiding judge since 2001.
Impeachment bill
Keller also faces possible impeachment in the Texas House related to her role in allegedly denying court access to death row inmate Michael Richard in 2007. State Rep. Lon Burnam, D-Fort Worth, said he believed the latest disclosure about Keller's financial statements increases the chances that his impeachment proposal will receive a hearing.
Keller has denied any wrongdoing. In a response to the ethics charges filed with the judicial conduct commission, her attorney in that case claimed the charges were unconstitutional because the commission had refused to pay for his legal services.
Lawyer Chip Babcock said Keller's defense costs could be "financially ruinous." He said he based his assessment on Keller's $152,500 salary and some rental income. He was not aware of the full extent of her holdings, he said, until told by The News.
On Tuesday, Babcock said his legal position on Keller's costs had not changed. But he referred calls about the latest ethics complaints to Shack.
Shack is a former attorney with the Texas secretary of state whose clients have included state Supreme Court Justice Nathan Hecht and Lt. Gov. David Dewhurst.
Justice Hecht is appealing a ruling by the state ethics commission that he received an improper gift of reduced legal services from Babcock's law firm.
Texans for Public Justice has accused Dewhurst, one of the state's wealthiest officeholders, of failing to make full disclosure of assets in a blind trust. The complaint against the lieutenant governor is pending.
Labels:
Appellate Courts,
News Clips
Tuesday, March 31, 2009
Dallas Morning News: Whatever judge is hiding, it's not good sense
Just what is Judge Sharon Keller trying to pull? The controversial presiding judge on the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals has claimed it would be "financially ruinous" to have to defend herself against ethics charges stemming from her infamous conduct in the Michael Richard death penalty appeal case. When that didn't work to get the charges dismissed, Keller asked Texas taxpayers to foot the bill for her defense before the state Commission on Judicial Conduct. Read the article at the Dallas Morning News
Dallas Morning News Editorial
Just what is Judge Sharon Keller trying to pull?
The controversial presiding judge on the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals has claimed it would be "financially ruinous" to have to defend herself against ethics charges stemming from her infamous conduct in the Michael Richard death penalty appeal case. When that didn't work to get the charges dismissed, Keller asked Texas taxpayers to foot the bill for her defense before the state Commission on Judicial Conduct.
Surprise, surprise: Keller's no indigent. As The Dallas Morning News' Steve McGonigle revealed yesterday, the judge failed to disclose more than $2 million in real estate holdings, as required by law. She might even be far wealthier than that; McGonigle's report concerned only those assets the judge is forced by law to declare publicly.
Did Keller intentionally hide this financial information from the public, or was this merely an incompetent oversight? Only Keller knows for sure.
What we have, then, is a multimillionaire jurist concealing her assets and pleading poverty for the sake of a state subsidy. Whatever the legal ins and outs of this sorry mess, in the court of public opinion, this is an open-and-shut case of facts evasion.
Whether the disclosure flap is a sin of commission or omission, it reveals that a top Texas judge lacks something essential to the performance of her job: good judgment.
Then again, that was clear when her petty refusal to keep the courthouse doors open past 5 p.m. to accommodate computer problems sent inmate Michael Richard to an untimely death.
Whatever Keller ultimately has to pay in her own defense, she's getting a better deal than she gave him.
Editorial: Whatever judge is hiding, it's not good sense
March 31, 2009Dallas Morning News Editorial
Just what is Judge Sharon Keller trying to pull?
The controversial presiding judge on the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals has claimed it would be "financially ruinous" to have to defend herself against ethics charges stemming from her infamous conduct in the Michael Richard death penalty appeal case. When that didn't work to get the charges dismissed, Keller asked Texas taxpayers to foot the bill for her defense before the state Commission on Judicial Conduct.
Surprise, surprise: Keller's no indigent. As The Dallas Morning News' Steve McGonigle revealed yesterday, the judge failed to disclose more than $2 million in real estate holdings, as required by law. She might even be far wealthier than that; McGonigle's report concerned only those assets the judge is forced by law to declare publicly.
Did Keller intentionally hide this financial information from the public, or was this merely an incompetent oversight? Only Keller knows for sure.
What we have, then, is a multimillionaire jurist concealing her assets and pleading poverty for the sake of a state subsidy. Whatever the legal ins and outs of this sorry mess, in the court of public opinion, this is an open-and-shut case of facts evasion.
Whether the disclosure flap is a sin of commission or omission, it reveals that a top Texas judge lacks something essential to the performance of her job: good judgment.
Then again, that was clear when her petty refusal to keep the courthouse doors open past 5 p.m. to accommodate computer problems sent inmate Michael Richard to an untimely death.
Whatever Keller ultimately has to pay in her own defense, she's getting a better deal than she gave him.
Labels:
Appellate Courts,
News Clips
TPJ Files Criminal Complaint Against Judge Keller
Texans for Public Justice (TPJ) filed complaints today with prosecutors and the Texas Ethics Commission alleging that Texas Court of Criminal Appeals Presiding Judge Sharon Keller illegally failed to disclose millions of dollars worth of real estate holdings in sworn personal financial disclosure statements. TPJ's complaints follow up on revelations reported Monday by the Dallas Morning News.
Read the full media release
View the Texas Ethics Commission complaint
View the complaint letter to Travis County Attorney
Read the full media release
View the Texas Ethics Commission complaint
View the complaint letter to Travis County Attorney
Labels:
Appellate Courts,
Ethics Complaints,
Press Releases
Monday, March 30, 2009
Dallas Morning News: Judge Keller's disclosures omit nearly $2 million in real estate, public records show
The presiding judge of the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals, while seeking state aid to defend herself against ethics charges, failed to abide by legal requirements that she disclose nearly $2 million in real estate holdings, according to an analysis of public records by The Dallas Morning News. Read the article at the Dallas Morning News
By STEVE McGONIGLE / The Dallas Morning News
smcgonigle@dallasnews.com
The presiding judge of the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals, while seeking state aid to defend herself against ethics charges, failed to abide by legal requirements that she disclose nearly $2 million in real estate holdings, according to an analysis of public records by The Dallas Morning News.
Sharon Keller has sought dismissal of the charges on grounds that it would be "financially ruinous" for her to pay private counsel to fight allegations brought by the state Commission on Judicial Conduct that she violated her duties in a death penalty appeal.
Keller, the state's highest criminal court judge, faces possible removal from office if a special master agrees that she blocked a condemned inmate's last-minute effort to stop his execution in 2007 by refusing to extend the court's 5 p.m. closing time to allow his lawyers to file their plea. The inmate, Michael Richard, was executed within hours.
Keller has denied any wrongdoing in the Richard case. She did not respond to several requests for comment on the property disclosures, made in two calls to her Austin office, as well as via her lawyer.
She has also argued that the charges violate her constitutional right to counsel because the state refuses to allow her current attorney, Chip Babcock, to represent her at taxpayer expense. Babcock has said he would represent Keller for almost nothing, but that he believes state ethics rules prohibit him from doing that. He said he asked the state Ethics Commission for a clarification in Keller's case, but the commission declined to give one.
Babcock, a partner in one of the largest law firms in Texas, said that the proceeding could cost Keller several hundred thousand dollars and that it could consume most if not all of her income and assets.
He said he based his prediction on the resources Keller listed on her latest personal financial report to the state and had not asked to see any other financial statements from his client, a member of a well-known Dallas family.
Sworn statement
The sworn statement Keller was required to file with the Texas Ethics Commission last April reflected income of more than $275,000, including her annual state salary of $152,500. It also showed that she owned at least 100 shares of airline stock, a home in Austin and one commercial property in Dallas. County tax records valued the properties at about $1 million.
Keller's statement did not list her ownership interest in seven other residential and commercial properties in Dallas and Tarrant counties. Those properties are valued collectively by county appraisal districts at about $1.9 million.
Among Keller's unlisted properties are two homes valued together at just over $1 million in the family's compound across from the Dallas Arboretum. Keller is listed as sole owner under Sharon Batjer, her married name. She was divorced in 1982.
The other omissions include two Keller-owned properties valued at about $823,000: a vacant commercial site in Euless and an occupied commercial property next to Keller's Drive-In on East Northwest Highway, a landmark hamburger restaurant operated since 1965 by the judge's father, Jack. Also not disclosed are three properties valued at $114,000 and owned by Keller's 27-year-old son, a law student whom she claims as a dependent.
The Texas Government Code requires state officeholders to disclose "all beneficial interests in real property" held by the official, a spouse or any dependents. Failure to comply could subject the officeholder to civil and criminal penalties.
The Texas Ethics Commission does not routinely check the accuracy or completeness of financial disclosure reports, only that they have been filed, said Tim Sorrells, the commission's deputy general counsel.
The judge's assets
Keller's lawyer, Babcock, said he was not aware of the extent of her holdings until told about them by The News.
Babcock then acknowledged that Keller might be able to sell enough property to pay her legal bills. But he said the amount of Keller's assets should not alter their legal position that she should be allowed to benefit from reduced attorney's fees or be provided his legal services at state expense.
"The argument ought to be the same whether you came to the bench after having amassed substantial assets or you inherited it, or you don't have any assets," he said.
Keller's assets, including those she is not required to disclose to the state, could reveal that she is even wealthier.
Her 2008 statement to the ethics commission did not list about $3 million in real estate held by three family corporations or trusts, in which she has an interest. State law requires that officeholders list any corporations in which they are an officer or director. Keller did not do so for the three family-run entities, although she did acknowledge earning income of at least $25,000 from a trust in her father's name.
State law does not require asset disclosure if the officeholder does not have at least a 50 percent interest. Records do not show Keller's percentage holdings, and neither she nor her lawyer would comment on any details of The News' findings. Keller also did not list two properties worth about $796,000, owned by a family corporation in which her dependent son is an officer, as she is required by law to do.
Officeholders are also required to list outstanding debt over $1,000; Keller listed none on her latest report to the ethics commission.
Last year, Keller bought a residential property in Hunt County, valued on tax rolls at $251,000. She will not have to report that property until this year's filing.
'Extremely outrageous'
Andrew Wheat, research director of Texans for Public Justice, the Austin-based watchdog group that monitors officeholder finances, decried Keller's omissions as an "extremely outrageous" betrayal of the public trust.
"It leaves one speechless to see so much left out of her personal financial statements on the one hand and then on the other hand to see her making her claims that hiring a private attorney would be financially ruinous," he said.
While it is possible that some of the properties might be exempt from disclosure, Wheat said, the majority of omissions appear to fall within the law's requirements.
"Is this an insane amount of carelessness year after year, in which case should this person be our highest criminal judge?" he said. "Is it willful hiding of assets, in which case that person probably isn't fit to be our top criminal judge? I don't know."
The News compiled a list of properties owned solely by Keller, her son, Temple, or in partnership with her parents or siblings and compared them with the sworn financial statements she filed with the state ethics commission between 2005 and 2008.
Keller omitted the same seven properties in each of her sworn reports, the review showed.
Judges, like all other state officeholders, are required to disclose their personal finances to allow the public to know their backgrounds and spot conflicts of interest that may require them to be disqualified from participating in a particular case.
In 1999, Keller transferred her ownership of one commercial property near Keller's Drive-In to another family-run corporation after The Dallas Observer reported the judge was the landlord for a strip club that occupied her property. The property is now occupied by a pawn shop.
One of the commercial properties Keller did not disclose involves a lease to a gas drilling company. The second property is leased to a rental car company. The family businesses in which she has an interest involve a bank in Arlington, a barbecue restaurant in Arlington and a medical clinic in Garland.
Chuck Herring, an Austin lawyer who specializes in legal ethics, said the ethics commission takes seriously the failure to comply with disclosure requirements.
"Sure, that's a problem," he said. "And it potentially can reflect upon the judge's performance of his or her duties and simply the openness of government that we require."
Judge Keller's disclosures omit nearly $2 million in real estate, public records show
Monday, March 30, 2009By STEVE McGONIGLE / The Dallas Morning News
smcgonigle@dallasnews.com
The presiding judge of the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals, while seeking state aid to defend herself against ethics charges, failed to abide by legal requirements that she disclose nearly $2 million in real estate holdings, according to an analysis of public records by The Dallas Morning News.
Sharon Keller has sought dismissal of the charges on grounds that it would be "financially ruinous" for her to pay private counsel to fight allegations brought by the state Commission on Judicial Conduct that she violated her duties in a death penalty appeal.
Keller, the state's highest criminal court judge, faces possible removal from office if a special master agrees that she blocked a condemned inmate's last-minute effort to stop his execution in 2007 by refusing to extend the court's 5 p.m. closing time to allow his lawyers to file their plea. The inmate, Michael Richard, was executed within hours.
Keller has denied any wrongdoing in the Richard case. She did not respond to several requests for comment on the property disclosures, made in two calls to her Austin office, as well as via her lawyer.
She has also argued that the charges violate her constitutional right to counsel because the state refuses to allow her current attorney, Chip Babcock, to represent her at taxpayer expense. Babcock has said he would represent Keller for almost nothing, but that he believes state ethics rules prohibit him from doing that. He said he asked the state Ethics Commission for a clarification in Keller's case, but the commission declined to give one.
Babcock, a partner in one of the largest law firms in Texas, said that the proceeding could cost Keller several hundred thousand dollars and that it could consume most if not all of her income and assets.
He said he based his prediction on the resources Keller listed on her latest personal financial report to the state and had not asked to see any other financial statements from his client, a member of a well-known Dallas family.
Sworn statement
The sworn statement Keller was required to file with the Texas Ethics Commission last April reflected income of more than $275,000, including her annual state salary of $152,500. It also showed that she owned at least 100 shares of airline stock, a home in Austin and one commercial property in Dallas. County tax records valued the properties at about $1 million.
Keller's statement did not list her ownership interest in seven other residential and commercial properties in Dallas and Tarrant counties. Those properties are valued collectively by county appraisal districts at about $1.9 million.
Among Keller's unlisted properties are two homes valued together at just over $1 million in the family's compound across from the Dallas Arboretum. Keller is listed as sole owner under Sharon Batjer, her married name. She was divorced in 1982.
The other omissions include two Keller-owned properties valued at about $823,000: a vacant commercial site in Euless and an occupied commercial property next to Keller's Drive-In on East Northwest Highway, a landmark hamburger restaurant operated since 1965 by the judge's father, Jack. Also not disclosed are three properties valued at $114,000 and owned by Keller's 27-year-old son, a law student whom she claims as a dependent.
The Texas Government Code requires state officeholders to disclose "all beneficial interests in real property" held by the official, a spouse or any dependents. Failure to comply could subject the officeholder to civil and criminal penalties.
The Texas Ethics Commission does not routinely check the accuracy or completeness of financial disclosure reports, only that they have been filed, said Tim Sorrells, the commission's deputy general counsel.
The judge's assets
Keller's lawyer, Babcock, said he was not aware of the extent of her holdings until told about them by The News.
Babcock then acknowledged that Keller might be able to sell enough property to pay her legal bills. But he said the amount of Keller's assets should not alter their legal position that she should be allowed to benefit from reduced attorney's fees or be provided his legal services at state expense.
"The argument ought to be the same whether you came to the bench after having amassed substantial assets or you inherited it, or you don't have any assets," he said.
Keller's assets, including those she is not required to disclose to the state, could reveal that she is even wealthier.
Her 2008 statement to the ethics commission did not list about $3 million in real estate held by three family corporations or trusts, in which she has an interest. State law requires that officeholders list any corporations in which they are an officer or director. Keller did not do so for the three family-run entities, although she did acknowledge earning income of at least $25,000 from a trust in her father's name.
State law does not require asset disclosure if the officeholder does not have at least a 50 percent interest. Records do not show Keller's percentage holdings, and neither she nor her lawyer would comment on any details of The News' findings. Keller also did not list two properties worth about $796,000, owned by a family corporation in which her dependent son is an officer, as she is required by law to do.
Officeholders are also required to list outstanding debt over $1,000; Keller listed none on her latest report to the ethics commission.
Last year, Keller bought a residential property in Hunt County, valued on tax rolls at $251,000. She will not have to report that property until this year's filing.
'Extremely outrageous'
Andrew Wheat, research director of Texans for Public Justice, the Austin-based watchdog group that monitors officeholder finances, decried Keller's omissions as an "extremely outrageous" betrayal of the public trust.
"It leaves one speechless to see so much left out of her personal financial statements on the one hand and then on the other hand to see her making her claims that hiring a private attorney would be financially ruinous," he said.
While it is possible that some of the properties might be exempt from disclosure, Wheat said, the majority of omissions appear to fall within the law's requirements.
"Is this an insane amount of carelessness year after year, in which case should this person be our highest criminal judge?" he said. "Is it willful hiding of assets, in which case that person probably isn't fit to be our top criminal judge? I don't know."
The News compiled a list of properties owned solely by Keller, her son, Temple, or in partnership with her parents or siblings and compared them with the sworn financial statements she filed with the state ethics commission between 2005 and 2008.
Keller omitted the same seven properties in each of her sworn reports, the review showed.
Judges, like all other state officeholders, are required to disclose their personal finances to allow the public to know their backgrounds and spot conflicts of interest that may require them to be disqualified from participating in a particular case.
In 1999, Keller transferred her ownership of one commercial property near Keller's Drive-In to another family-run corporation after The Dallas Observer reported the judge was the landlord for a strip club that occupied her property. The property is now occupied by a pawn shop.
One of the commercial properties Keller did not disclose involves a lease to a gas drilling company. The second property is leased to a rental car company. The family businesses in which she has an interest involve a bank in Arlington, a barbecue restaurant in Arlington and a medical clinic in Garland.
Chuck Herring, an Austin lawyer who specializes in legal ethics, said the ethics commission takes seriously the failure to comply with disclosure requirements.
"Sure, that's a problem," he said. "And it potentially can reflect upon the judge's performance of his or her duties and simply the openness of government that we require."
Labels:
Appellate Courts,
News Clips
Friday, January 2, 2009
Austin American-Statesman: DeLay-related ruling shows polarization of 3rd Court
The 3rd Court of Appeals in Austin, split along partisan lines, has ruled that Republican Justice Alan Waldrop did not have to excuse himself from a case against two associates of former U.S. Rep. Tom DeLay, R-Sugar Land.The ruling does not immediately affect the money-laundering charges against DeLay and his associates, John Colyandro and Jim Ellis. But the justices question one another's motives in how the polarizing case has been handled by the appellate court.
Read the article at the Austin American-Statesman
3RD COURT OF APPEALS
By Laylan Copelin
AUSTIN AMERICAN-STATESMAN
Friday, January 02, 2009
The 3rd Court of Appeals in Austin, split along partisan lines, has ruled that Republican Justice Alan Waldrop did not have to excuse himself from a case against two associates of former U.S. Rep. Tom DeLay, R-Sugar Land.
The ruling does not immediately affect the money-laundering charges against DeLay and his associates, John Colyandro and Jim Ellis. But the justices question one another's motives in how the polarizing case has been handled by the appellate court.
The opinion and the dissents were filed New Year's Eve as two principals in the case, Chief Justice Ken Law and Travis County District Attorney Ronnie Earle, exited the public arena.
Earle, a Democrat who has been pursuing the money-laundering case since the 2002 elections, has retired after 32 years in office. Law's term ended Wednesday because the GOP justice was defeated in November, in part because of questions about the case.
DeLay and his associates are accused of laundering corporate money, which is banned in connection with political campaigns in Texas, into donations to Republican candidates during the 2002 elections.
DeLay had to resign as U.S. House majority leader because of the indictment and later retired from Congress.
Three years ago Ellis and Colyandro separately challenged the constitutionality of the state law. All three are awaiting trial.
In August, Justices Waldrop, Law and Robert Pemberton, all Republicans, upheld the constitutionality of the money-laundering statute but added that they did not think that the law in 2002 covered checks. The $190,000 in the DeLay case involved corporate checks, not cash.
That ruling prompted a firestorm. Prosecutors argued that the three-judge panel had gone beyond the legal question before it. Earle spoke of "the dark shadow of corruption" looming over the case as he filed a motion asking Waldrop to withdraw or be dropped from the case. His complaint was that before Waldrop became a justice, he helped a group of DeLay's political allies, Texans for Lawsuit Reform, stay out of a lawsuit arising from the same circumstances as the criminal case.
Waldrop characterized the lawsuit as "politically motivated."
Two Democratic justices on the 3rd Court objected.
Justice Diane Henson complained that her GOP colleagues were wrong about the money-laundering law and had bottled up the case for years to thwart prosecution of the high-profile case.
Justice Jan Patterson accused Law of ignoring her dissent when the 3rd Court ruled earlier this year on Waldrop's standing in the case. She also questioned why the two men's constitutional challenges were combined into one case and assigned to an all-Republican panel of justices to consider. Previously one man's challenge was assigned to an all-GOP panel and the other case was being handled by a panel containing one Democrat.
On Wednesday, the Republican majority struck back in an opinion written by Justice David Puryear. Law and Pemberton joined in Puryear's opinion.
Puryear criticized Patterson's "attempts to insert suspicion and intrigue into what have been routine decisions by this Court." He wrote that the two challenges were combined because they were identical cases and because a Democratic justice would be retiring soon and the cases might take awhile to deal with. He accused Henson of just "rehashing" her earlier complaints that Waldrop's ruling on money-laundering had been wrongly decided instead of focusing on whether Waldrop should have stayed on the case.
The Republican justices said Earle should have known about Waldrop's role with Texans for Lawsuit Reform because it had been publicized. They said it would be wrong to let one side wait to complain about a justice until the parties in the case see which way he rules.
Henson argued that a reasonable person would question whether Waldrop might favor DeLay's associates because of his earlier work with DeLay's political allies.
"One might also question why, if Justice Waldrop's lack of bias or partiality is so obvious, a 38-page opinion, including personal attacks on dissenting justices, was necessary to explain why the motion to recuse was denied," she wrote.
lcopelin@statesman.com; 445-3617
Read the article at the Austin American-Statesman
3RD COURT OF APPEALS
DeLay-related ruling shows polarization of 3rd Court
Court says GOP justice did not have to excuse himself from case dealing with associates of former House majority leader.By Laylan Copelin
AUSTIN AMERICAN-STATESMAN
Friday, January 02, 2009
The 3rd Court of Appeals in Austin, split along partisan lines, has ruled that Republican Justice Alan Waldrop did not have to excuse himself from a case against two associates of former U.S. Rep. Tom DeLay, R-Sugar Land.
The ruling does not immediately affect the money-laundering charges against DeLay and his associates, John Colyandro and Jim Ellis. But the justices question one another's motives in how the polarizing case has been handled by the appellate court.
![]() Ken Law lost re-election bid in November. |
The opinion and the dissents were filed New Year's Eve as two principals in the case, Chief Justice Ken Law and Travis County District Attorney Ronnie Earle, exited the public arena.
Earle, a Democrat who has been pursuing the money-laundering case since the 2002 elections, has retired after 32 years in office. Law's term ended Wednesday because the GOP justice was defeated in November, in part because of questions about the case.
DeLay and his associates are accused of laundering corporate money, which is banned in connection with political campaigns in Texas, into donations to Republican candidates during the 2002 elections.
DeLay had to resign as U.S. House majority leader because of the indictment and later retired from Congress.
Three years ago Ellis and Colyandro separately challenged the constitutionality of the state law. All three are awaiting trial.
In August, Justices Waldrop, Law and Robert Pemberton, all Republicans, upheld the constitutionality of the money-laundering statute but added that they did not think that the law in 2002 covered checks. The $190,000 in the DeLay case involved corporate checks, not cash.
That ruling prompted a firestorm. Prosecutors argued that the three-judge panel had gone beyond the legal question before it. Earle spoke of "the dark shadow of corruption" looming over the case as he filed a motion asking Waldrop to withdraw or be dropped from the case. His complaint was that before Waldrop became a justice, he helped a group of DeLay's political allies, Texans for Lawsuit Reform, stay out of a lawsuit arising from the same circumstances as the criminal case.
Waldrop characterized the lawsuit as "politically motivated."
Two Democratic justices on the 3rd Court objected.
Justice Diane Henson complained that her GOP colleagues were wrong about the money-laundering law and had bottled up the case for years to thwart prosecution of the high-profile case.
Justice Jan Patterson accused Law of ignoring her dissent when the 3rd Court ruled earlier this year on Waldrop's standing in the case. She also questioned why the two men's constitutional challenges were combined into one case and assigned to an all-Republican panel of justices to consider. Previously one man's challenge was assigned to an all-GOP panel and the other case was being handled by a panel containing one Democrat.
On Wednesday, the Republican majority struck back in an opinion written by Justice David Puryear. Law and Pemberton joined in Puryear's opinion.
Puryear criticized Patterson's "attempts to insert suspicion and intrigue into what have been routine decisions by this Court." He wrote that the two challenges were combined because they were identical cases and because a Democratic justice would be retiring soon and the cases might take awhile to deal with. He accused Henson of just "rehashing" her earlier complaints that Waldrop's ruling on money-laundering had been wrongly decided instead of focusing on whether Waldrop should have stayed on the case.
The Republican justices said Earle should have known about Waldrop's role with Texans for Lawsuit Reform because it had been publicized. They said it would be wrong to let one side wait to complain about a justice until the parties in the case see which way he rules.
Henson argued that a reasonable person would question whether Waldrop might favor DeLay's associates because of his earlier work with DeLay's political allies.
"One might also question why, if Justice Waldrop's lack of bias or partiality is so obvious, a 38-page opinion, including personal attacks on dissenting justices, was necessary to explain why the motion to recuse was denied," she wrote.
lcopelin@statesman.com; 445-3617
Labels:
Appellate Courts,
News Clips,
Tom Delay/TRMPAC
Tuesday, October 14, 2008
TPJ Files Complaint Against Justice Waldrop in TRMPAC Case
Texans for Public Justice filed a complaint with the State Commission on Judicial Conduct today alleging that Third Court of Appeals Justice Alan Waldrop should not have written an opinion in the criminal case against Texans for a Republican Majority (TRMPAC) because his impartiality is questionable. 
Texans for Public Justice filed a complaint with the State Commission on Judicial Conduct today alleging that Third Court of Appeals Justice Alan Waldrop should not have written an opinion in the criminal case against Texans for a Republican Majority (TRMPAC) because his impartiality is questionable.
“Justice Waldrop’s August 22 TRMPAC opinion reads like a ‘Get Out of Jail Free Card’ for Tom DeLay and his cronies,” said Texans for Public Justice Director Craig McDonald. “As counsel for Texans for Lawsuit Reform (TLR) in related civil litigation, Waldrop announced his bias in this matter years ago, dismissing the civil suit as ‘politically motivated.’ Waldrop should not have participated in this case.”
Waldrop’s TRMPAC opinion upheld the constitutionality of the indictments against two DeLay associates who are charged with laundering corporate money into the 2002 Texas elections. Yet Waldrop also tackled an issue that was not before his court when he wrote that state money-laundering laws did not apply to checks at the time of the alleged TRMPAC crimes. These money-laundering allegations are central to the TRMPAC case.
Given Waldrop’s ties to the case, judicial ethics expert Robert Schuwerk of the University of Houston Law School told the Austin American-Statesman that “the judge shouldn’t have written that opinion.”
Travis County District Attorney Ronnie Earle petitioned Justice Waldrop to recuse himself from further participation in the TRMPAC case on September 23. The Third Court of Appeals rejected this motion without comment on October 10.
Read the TPJ complaint
Access a copy of Waldrop's TLR civil filing

TPJ Files Complaint Against Justice Waldrop in TRMPAC Case
| For Immediate Release: | For More Information Contact: |
| October 14, 2008 | Craig McDonald, 512-472-9770 |
Texans for Public Justice filed a complaint with the State Commission on Judicial Conduct today alleging that Third Court of Appeals Justice Alan Waldrop should not have written an opinion in the criminal case against Texans for a Republican Majority (TRMPAC) because his impartiality is questionable.
“Justice Waldrop’s August 22 TRMPAC opinion reads like a ‘Get Out of Jail Free Card’ for Tom DeLay and his cronies,” said Texans for Public Justice Director Craig McDonald. “As counsel for Texans for Lawsuit Reform (TLR) in related civil litigation, Waldrop announced his bias in this matter years ago, dismissing the civil suit as ‘politically motivated.’ Waldrop should not have participated in this case.”
Waldrop’s TRMPAC opinion upheld the constitutionality of the indictments against two DeLay associates who are charged with laundering corporate money into the 2002 Texas elections. Yet Waldrop also tackled an issue that was not before his court when he wrote that state money-laundering laws did not apply to checks at the time of the alleged TRMPAC crimes. These money-laundering allegations are central to the TRMPAC case.
Given Waldrop’s ties to the case, judicial ethics expert Robert Schuwerk of the University of Houston Law School told the Austin American-Statesman that “the judge shouldn’t have written that opinion.”
Travis County District Attorney Ronnie Earle petitioned Justice Waldrop to recuse himself from further participation in the TRMPAC case on September 23. The Third Court of Appeals rejected this motion without comment on October 10.
Read the TPJ complaint
Access a copy of Waldrop's TLR civil filing
Associated Press: Justice says chief justice blocked her dissent
A state appeals court justice wants the Texas Supreme Court to intervene after she says Chief Justice Ken Law refused to file her dissent in a case involving two associates of former U.S. House Majority Leader Tom DeLay. On Tuesday, Texans for Public Justice filed a complaint with the State Commission on Judicial Conduct alleging that Justice Allan Waldrop should not have written the opinion in August that upheld the constitutionality of the law on money laundering.
© 2008 The Associated Press
Oct. 14, 2008
AUSTIN — A state appeals court justice wants the Texas Supreme Court to intervene after she says Chief Justice Ken Law refused to file her dissent in a case involving two associates of former U.S. House Majority Leader Tom DeLay.
Justice Jan Patterson, a Democrat on the Austin-based 3rd Court of Appeals, claims that Law, a Republican who's up for re-election, blocked the filing of her dissent to a ruling last week that overruled a motion asking Justice Alan Waldrop to step aside in the money-laundering case involving DeLay's associates, the Austin American-Statesman reports in its Tuesday editions.
DeLay and his associates, John Colyandro of Austin and Jim Ellis of Washington, have been accused of laundering corporate money into political donations to Republican candidates in 2002. Use of corporate money is generally banned from state campaigns.
Before any trial, Ellis and Colyandro challenged the constitutionality of the law.
Last month, Travis County District Attorney Ronnie Earle asked the court to remove Waldrop because Earle claimed Waldrop betrayed his bias four years ago, before he became a judge, when he called a similar money-laundering allegations in a related civil lawsuit "politically motivated" and an attempt to "harass political opponents." At the time, Waldrop was representing a client who was a political ally of DeLay.
Waldrop wrote an opinion in August that upheld the constitutionality of the law on money laundering but warned that the prosecutors had a fatal flaw in their case, a view that two trial judges and one other appellate judges have disagreed with.
Waldrop, Law and a third Republican justice, Robert Pemberton, wrote that the charges against DeLay and his associates should be dismissed because they used a check, not cash, in their transaction. Waldrop argued that the law — before it was changed in 2005 — did not cover checks during the 2002 election.
Patterson declined to comment beyond her filing late Friday afternoon. Law did not immediately return a call from The Associated Press on Tuesday.
In a reply to the Texas Supreme Court, Law denied that he tried to suppress Patterson's dissent, the American-Statesman reported Tuesday. He said he was only trying to make her follow the court's internal procedures by circulating her opinion first among colleagues to give them the opportunity to respond.
"Justice Patterson was informed ... that she would not be allowed to circumvent the court's circulation policy ..." Law wrote in his reply. "Justice Patterson's dissenting opinion is currently in circulation at the court and will be released together with any other opinions in the matter upon completion of that process."
On Tuesday, Texans for Public Justice filed a complaint with the State Commission on Judicial Conduct alleging that Waldrop should not have written the opinion. The Austin-based group that tracks money in politics said in a statement that Waldrop's "impartiality is questionable."
Justice says chief justice blocked her dissent
© 2008 The Associated Press
Oct. 14, 2008
AUSTIN — A state appeals court justice wants the Texas Supreme Court to intervene after she says Chief Justice Ken Law refused to file her dissent in a case involving two associates of former U.S. House Majority Leader Tom DeLay.
Justice Jan Patterson, a Democrat on the Austin-based 3rd Court of Appeals, claims that Law, a Republican who's up for re-election, blocked the filing of her dissent to a ruling last week that overruled a motion asking Justice Alan Waldrop to step aside in the money-laundering case involving DeLay's associates, the Austin American-Statesman reports in its Tuesday editions.
DeLay and his associates, John Colyandro of Austin and Jim Ellis of Washington, have been accused of laundering corporate money into political donations to Republican candidates in 2002. Use of corporate money is generally banned from state campaigns.
Before any trial, Ellis and Colyandro challenged the constitutionality of the law.
Last month, Travis County District Attorney Ronnie Earle asked the court to remove Waldrop because Earle claimed Waldrop betrayed his bias four years ago, before he became a judge, when he called a similar money-laundering allegations in a related civil lawsuit "politically motivated" and an attempt to "harass political opponents." At the time, Waldrop was representing a client who was a political ally of DeLay.
Waldrop wrote an opinion in August that upheld the constitutionality of the law on money laundering but warned that the prosecutors had a fatal flaw in their case, a view that two trial judges and one other appellate judges have disagreed with.
Waldrop, Law and a third Republican justice, Robert Pemberton, wrote that the charges against DeLay and his associates should be dismissed because they used a check, not cash, in their transaction. Waldrop argued that the law — before it was changed in 2005 — did not cover checks during the 2002 election.
Patterson declined to comment beyond her filing late Friday afternoon. Law did not immediately return a call from The Associated Press on Tuesday.
In a reply to the Texas Supreme Court, Law denied that he tried to suppress Patterson's dissent, the American-Statesman reported Tuesday. He said he was only trying to make her follow the court's internal procedures by circulating her opinion first among colleagues to give them the opportunity to respond.
"Justice Patterson was informed ... that she would not be allowed to circumvent the court's circulation policy ..." Law wrote in his reply. "Justice Patterson's dissenting opinion is currently in circulation at the court and will be released together with any other opinions in the matter upon completion of that process."
On Tuesday, Texans for Public Justice filed a complaint with the State Commission on Judicial Conduct alleging that Waldrop should not have written the opinion. The Austin-based group that tracks money in politics said in a statement that Waldrop's "impartiality is questionable."
Friday, September 26, 2008
Houston Chronicle: Travis County DA asks for judge's removal from case
A Republican appellate justice who once had political ties to Tom DeLay should remove himself from a case involving DeLay's associates, Travis County District Attorney Ronnie Earle said. The justice, Alan Waldrop, and two other Republican justices, Ken Law and Bob Pemberton, were a panel of the Third Court of Appeals that recently opened the door to the possible dismissal of criminal charges against the former U.S. House GOP leader.Read the article at the Houston Chronicle
By CLAY ROBISON
Copyright 2008 Houston Chronicle Austin Bureau
Sept. 26, 2008
AUSTIN — A Republican appellate justice who once had political ties to Tom DeLay should remove himself from a case involving DeLay's associates, Travis County District Attorney Ronnie Earle said.
The justice, Alan Waldrop, and two other Republican justices, Ken Law and Bob Pemberton, were a panel of the Third Court of Appeals that recently opened the door to the possible dismissal of criminal charges against the former U.S. House GOP leader.
DeLay and his associates — political consultants John Colyandro and Jim Ellis — are accused of illegally funneling $190,000 in corporate donations through a political committee formed by DeLay to seven Texas House candidates in 2002. Prosecutors allege they conspired to violate the state's ban on corporate contributions by laundering money through national Republican Party accounts.
Checks excluded
The committee, Texans for a Republican Majority (TRMPAC), helped the GOP capture a majority of Texas House seats that year.
Last month, Waldrop, Law and Pemberton refused to dismiss money laundering and conspiracy charges against Colyandro and Ellis, upholding the ban on corporate donations. But, in their ruling, they said the money laundering statute on the books in 2002 applied to cash, not checks.
DeLay wasn't part of the appeal, but he faces the same charges. And his attorney, Dick DeGuerin, believes the ruling will force prosecutors to eventually dismiss the charges because the indictment alleges the transactions were conducted with checks. The Legislature didn't add checks to the definition of "funds" in the money laundering law until 2005.
Waldrop, who wrote the opinion, was a paid lobbyist in 2002 for Texans for Lawsuit Reform, which hasn't been accused of any wrongdoing but worked closely with TRMPAC on House races.
Earle said he only recently learned that Waldrop, as TLR's lawyer, also filed a pleading in a civil lawsuit against TRMPAC, in which he characterized the allegations of corporate contributions as "politically motivated."
In motions filed this week, Earle asked the entire six-member appellate court to rehear the appeal and for Waldrop to recuse himself from further participation.
Too late for removal
Earle noted that the rules of civil procedure require a judge to abstain from a case if his impartiality might be reasonably questioned.
DeGuerin said it was too late for Earle to try to remove Waldrop from the case.
"You can't wait until you get an unfavorable ruling and then try to dismiss the judge," he said.
Waldrop, Law and Pemberton also have taken at least $119,825 in political donations from 20 groups and individuals who helped finance TRMPAC, according to Texans for Public Justice, a watchdog group often at odds with Texans for Lawsuit Reform, Waldrop's former client.
The donors, who have contributed to one or more of the justices since 2004, include the Locke Lord Bissell & Liddell law firm, Houston home builder Bob Perry, Dallas businessman Harold Simmons, Dallas investor Peter O'Donnell, the Farmers insurance PAC, the AT&T PAC and San Antonio businessman James Leininger.
clay.robison@chron.com
Travis County DA asks for judge's removal from case
Earle points to Waldrop's political links to DeLayBy CLAY ROBISON
Copyright 2008 Houston Chronicle Austin Bureau
Sept. 26, 2008
AUSTIN — A Republican appellate justice who once had political ties to Tom DeLay should remove himself from a case involving DeLay's associates, Travis County District Attorney Ronnie Earle said.
The justice, Alan Waldrop, and two other Republican justices, Ken Law and Bob Pemberton, were a panel of the Third Court of Appeals that recently opened the door to the possible dismissal of criminal charges against the former U.S. House GOP leader.
DeLay and his associates — political consultants John Colyandro and Jim Ellis — are accused of illegally funneling $190,000 in corporate donations through a political committee formed by DeLay to seven Texas House candidates in 2002. Prosecutors allege they conspired to violate the state's ban on corporate contributions by laundering money through national Republican Party accounts.
Checks excluded
The committee, Texans for a Republican Majority (TRMPAC), helped the GOP capture a majority of Texas House seats that year.
Last month, Waldrop, Law and Pemberton refused to dismiss money laundering and conspiracy charges against Colyandro and Ellis, upholding the ban on corporate donations. But, in their ruling, they said the money laundering statute on the books in 2002 applied to cash, not checks.
DeLay wasn't part of the appeal, but he faces the same charges. And his attorney, Dick DeGuerin, believes the ruling will force prosecutors to eventually dismiss the charges because the indictment alleges the transactions were conducted with checks. The Legislature didn't add checks to the definition of "funds" in the money laundering law until 2005.
Waldrop, who wrote the opinion, was a paid lobbyist in 2002 for Texans for Lawsuit Reform, which hasn't been accused of any wrongdoing but worked closely with TRMPAC on House races.
Earle said he only recently learned that Waldrop, as TLR's lawyer, also filed a pleading in a civil lawsuit against TRMPAC, in which he characterized the allegations of corporate contributions as "politically motivated."
In motions filed this week, Earle asked the entire six-member appellate court to rehear the appeal and for Waldrop to recuse himself from further participation.
Too late for removal
Earle noted that the rules of civil procedure require a judge to abstain from a case if his impartiality might be reasonably questioned.
DeGuerin said it was too late for Earle to try to remove Waldrop from the case.
"You can't wait until you get an unfavorable ruling and then try to dismiss the judge," he said.
Waldrop, Law and Pemberton also have taken at least $119,825 in political donations from 20 groups and individuals who helped finance TRMPAC, according to Texans for Public Justice, a watchdog group often at odds with Texans for Lawsuit Reform, Waldrop's former client.
The donors, who have contributed to one or more of the justices since 2004, include the Locke Lord Bissell & Liddell law firm, Houston home builder Bob Perry, Dallas businessman Harold Simmons, Dallas investor Peter O'Donnell, the Farmers insurance PAC, the AT&T PAC and San Antonio businessman James Leininger.
clay.robison@chron.com
Labels:
Appellate Courts,
News Clips,
Tom Delay/TRMPAC
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






